Short answer: Review the pinned post as soon as the product, offer, or destination changes after launch. Keep it if a new profile visitor still gets the promised next step. Replace it if the post describes an old release state or sends visitors to a page that now answers a different question. Unpin it if there is no current, supportable post to replace it with. Save the old and new post URLs and the time of the change so reporting does not treat two different profile entry points as one.
A pin can outlive a launch schedule. A founder may keep posting updates while the profile’s first post still says “join the waitlist,” even though the product is now available. Or a launch page may redirect to a generic homepage that no longer explains the feature shown in the post. Both situations can confuse someone who found the company through a current conversation and then opened its profile. This worksheet focuses on the post-release review, after a pin was already chosen. If you are selecting the initial post, use our pinned X post selection worksheet.
Start with the promise a visitor actually sees
Read the pinned post without relying on internal launch context. Write down its headline claim, any date or availability statement, the visible call to action, and the destination after a click. Then open the link in a private browser window and on a phone. The important question is not whether the URL returns a page. It is whether the final page lets the visitor do what the post offered.
For example, “See the public demo” should lead to a currently available public demo or a page that clearly explains what has replaced it. If the demo is behind a login, if the release moved to a different product, or if the page only says “contact us,” the post and destination may no longer match. A redirect can be technically healthy while the visitor’s task fails. Check any form, download, or product step on the destination without submitting a test lead.
The pin also occupies a prominent position on the profile. X’s profile guidance explains how to pin and unpin a post. That platform control is simple; deciding what deserves the position requires an editorial check. Do not infer from the existence of a pin that X recommends or distributes it more widely. Here the value is a clearer first impression for people who visit the profile.
Use four possible decisions
The cases below are hypothetical examples, not Nowix client outcomes or measured performance. They show the distinction between a valid link and a valid next step.
| Current pin and destination | Visitor test | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Launch post says “join the waitlist”; product is now open to qualified teams. | Waitlist page still accepts names but no longer explains access. | Replace with a current availability post and tested product page; preserve the old URL in the launch record. |
| Feature post links to a release page that still explains the exact capability and offers a live demo. | Claim, access and call to action still match. | Keep, set a next review date and verify the link again after the next product change. |
| Post promises a demo; destination redirects to a broad homepage. | Home page has no route to that demo. | Replace or unpin while a specific destination is prepared. Do not call the redirect “fixed” merely because it loads. |
| Post describes a beta capability now withdrawn; no accurate replacement post exists. | An ordinary visitor would infer availability that is no longer true. | Unpin immediately; resolve the factual update separately before pinning another post. |
Choose keep when the post and destination remain useful together. Choose replace when a newer post can explain the current product state more accurately. Choose unpin when leaving the old post prominent would mislead and the replacement needs more work. Choose hold a proposed replacement when the new claim, page or publication approval is unfinished. A hold is not permission to leave an inaccurate old pin in place; unpinning may be the appropriate interim action.
Review the link as a path, not a string
Record the original URL in the post, the final URL after redirects, and the page’s visible action. Check whether the page is public to the intended audience, whether a product screenshot or claim still reflects the release, and whether the call to action works. If the post uses a shortened URL, expand it in the record. If there are geographic, account or device restrictions, note them next to the decision so a reviewer does not mistake a successful internal login for a public visitor experience.
Check tracking without treating it as proof of an outcome. Google Analytics’ campaign URL guidance explains that UTM parameters identify referring campaigns and that source, medium and campaign should be used consistently. If the old pin and new pin are meant to be compared, record the chosen parameter convention and the exact change time. Do not silently switch naming conventions midway and then attribute a change in reports to the copy. A click or session count by itself cannot prove that the pin caused a sale or even that every visitor saw the pin.
If a destination has changed since the original launch, inspect the entire route before deciding to keep the pin. A new page can be excellent but answer a different buyer question. An old announcement may point to a general “all products” page when a feature-specific page would let visitors verify the claim. The publishing owner should write down the reason for a destination choice, not merely paste the new link into a chat.
Write the replacement for today’s product state
A replacement post should explain what a profile visitor can do now. It may be a concise product explanation, a current demo walkthrough, or an account-positioning post that directs readers to the relevant page. Avoid pretending the release happened today if it did not. If the product changed, say what changed; if only the entry page changed, explain the same capability with a current destination.
Before pinning, have the product owner check the exact claim and availability conditions. The founder or account owner checks that the voice is appropriate for their account. The publishing owner checks the live destination, preview, accessibility of any visual, and scheduling. X’s help page documents the pin and unpin steps; use the account’s current interface when doing the change. Do not assume that an old post can be edited to repair its link. If editing is unavailable or would obscure what the launch audience originally saw, a new post with a clear current message is usually easier to audit.
Keep the old post URL even after it is unpinned. The historical post can remain part of the release record, and any later reporting needs to distinguish traffic before and after the replacement. If the old post contains a factually wrong claim, address that separately under your correction process. Moving it off the profile does not make the underlying statement true.
Copy this post-launch pin review record
Use one short record for each review. It can live with the launch notes or monthly account publishing plan.
Account and review time: profile URL, local date and reviewer.
Current pin: post URL, exact claim, call to action and linked URL.
Visitor path: final destination, access conditions and working next step.
Product state: what is available today, source and product owner.
Decision: keep, replace or unpin; short reason and approvers.
Replacement: new post URL, destination, tracking convention and pin time.
Reporting boundary: old pin end time, new pin start time and next review date.
Do not leave “check later” as the only owner instruction. Name the person who can verify a product claim and the person who can change the profile. A useful trigger might be the end of a launch offer, a release-note change, a new landing page, or a monthly account review. A newly scheduled post is not a replacement until someone confirms it is actually pinned and the previous pin is gone.
Work directly with Knowix on the account decision
Knowix can help a founder or marketing team review the current X profile, test the pinned post’s visitor path, write a replacement in the founder’s voice, and coordinate publishing and reporting. Our X account management service covers account positioning, publishing and review. Bring the current pin URL, the product page you want visitors to use, and the person who can approve product claims. We can then agree on a clear keep, replace or unpin decision and the exact handoff for publication.
A pin refresh is a small operation, but it connects product truth, copy, link behavior and measurement. The best outcome is a profile that gives a new visitor an accurate next step today, with a record that lets the team understand what changed later.
Frequently asked questions
Should we keep the launch announcement pinned after release?
Keep it only while its claim, destination and next step remain current for a profile visitor. Review it when the product state or destination changes, and record who owns the decision.
Can we change the link inside the original X post?
Do not assume an existing post can be edited. Check the account's current editing options and timing; when the post cannot be safely revised, publish and pin a new post or unpin the old one.
What if the launch landing page now redirects?
Test the full click path on a normal browser and a phone, including final destination, relevant promise and tracking parameters. A working redirect alone does not prove the page still meets the post's promise.
Does replacing a pin erase launch reporting?
It changes the profile's current entry point. Preserve the old post URL and reporting window, record the new post URL, and keep campaign parameters consistent so comparisons have context.
Who approves a new pinned post?
The product owner confirms current claims, the founder or account owner approves voice, and the publishing owner checks the destination and records the exact replacement time.